nausicaa83: (<doctor who> eleven)
[personal profile] nausicaa83
I'm back! Spent three lovely days with Tati, enjoyed the first days of Autumn immensely, wore my Erik Lehnsherr jacket for the first time in months. Other highlights of the last few days include cutting my thumb while peeling a potato, while on the phone with a friend of mine who was telling me about what her gynecologist told her last week. She was very scared (she has to take some meds, nothing serious, but she never had any health problems in 30 years so she was freaking out), and I couldn't interrupt her, so I managed to keep reassuring her in a calm, soothing voice, while rushing to the bathroom and trying to stop the bleeding with toilet paper. It was quite a lot of bleeding, because when I do something, I do it properly. Thinking about it, it must have looked quite funny. :D

I came home a couple of hours ago, and downloaded the latest Doctor Who episode, Asylum of the Daleks. Don't know what I was expecting - after loving the first episodes of the last season, I hated the ending, so I was very conflicted. I'm not sure whether I liked it or not. Spoilery review under the cut, I'll just leave this here, why on earth every freaking a time a girl talks about liking another girl, it is always called "a phase"? It pisses me off so much. So offensive.

First, I like this new companion. I wasn't expecting that, as I usually hate how Moffat writes female characters (the exception being River, up until she said her whole life revolved around the Doctor, and all that craziness with the wedding and so on). I do hope they won't go for "and he met her before her death", because it would be even lazier writing than the Mel storyline, going for the River Song paradox all over again. I bet he'll just re-write this universe and that'll be it.

I'm very happy they gave us some continuity with Demon's Run. I hated how they treated Amy's emotional trauma as a plot point and nothing more, so I was very surprised when it turned out that Amy and Rory weren't possessed, shapeshifters or whatever, they actually had some real, serious emotional baggage destroying their relationship. It still felt a bit rushed, but kudos for that.

I really, really loved what they did with the Daleks here. No pretty colours, just the good old fear that I got the first time I met the Daleks. The soul-deep horror and disgust at these creatures that are pure hatred. And the Asylum was an amazing idea and setting!

I was kind of expecting the final twist, since the Doctor first talked about the soufflè. It was easy once he made me focus on the right detail. It still was heart-breaking, and a beautiful ending.

I loved how Oswin's main feature was her brains. The girl sits there in a pretty red dress, a miniskirt, and flirts with Rory while the literal second thing we learn about her is that she had a very "adventorous" sex life, because that's what being bisex means (sorry for the bitterness, still offended). But then they concentrated on her being very smart, even smarter than the Doctor, and after being bludgeoned to the head many times with the fact that essentially the defining characteristic of Amy is that she is pretty, it was a welcome change of tune. I fear we'll have to wait until next Christmas to meet her again, so I'll just sit back and enjoy the aliens and the dinosaurs, but they managed to get me interested in her, and that's good.

And her name is amazing, I wasn't expecting that.

Forgot to post a picture here, but last week I got a new haircut (shorter and shorter), and died the bangs Tardis blue! I love it! *_____________*

Date: 2012-09-02 06:23 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] harriet-yuuko.livejournal.com
Concordo più o meno con la tua review dell'episodio! (è da oggi pomeriggio, quando l'ho visto, che ero qui ad attendere il tuo commento.XD)
Direi che mi è piaciuto, anche se l'idea notevolissima dell'Asylum e dei Dalek che sono ritenuti "pazzi" perché hanno qualcosa di umano poteva essere giocata meglio o tirata fuori di più: nella ricerca di scene d'azione, io questa tematica l'ho quasi persa.
Inizialmente la cosa di Amy e Rory mi aveva urtata per la fretta con cui è stata trattata. Il tuo punto di vista però in effetti è sensato: perlomeno c'è un riferimento al fatto che quegli eventi li hanno segnati!
Oswin è un amore e il plot twist apprezzabile e sbriciolacuore (io avevo intuito che c'era qualcosa di strano, ma non che sarebbe andato a parare proprio lì.) Mi domando come sarà reinserita più avanti. Non credo che Moffat abbia deciso di rigiocare la carta River (auto-copiarsi in una trama così particolare sarebbe un'idiozia, e anche se l'avesse pensata, non riesco a credere che qualcuno della produzione non gli abbia tirato qualcosa in testa per fargli cambiare idea!)
Non so bene come finirà questa cosa dei Dalek con la memoria cancellata, ma il momento finale in cui tutti cominciano a domandare "Doctor Who?" è stato epico.XD
Edited Date: 2012-09-02 06:24 pm (UTC)

Date: 2012-09-02 06:30 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] nausicaa83.livejournal.com
Infatti, io speravo si vedessero più Dalek "umani", meno Dalek ridotti all'Exterminate e basta. La scena del Dalek ballerina mi ha completamente straziato però. Bellissima scena davvero.

La cosa di Amy e Rory non aveva proprio alcun senso. Almeno con quella spiegazione mi viene credibile che Amy non parli di qualcosa così doloroso neppure con Rory, visto che lei non è mai stata il tipo da confidarsi, quindi direi salvati all'ultimo momento su quella storyline.

Io ci spero tantissimo che Moffat non si ripeta, anche se la cosa con Mel era davvero una cazzata enorme, proprio l'ABC del lazy writing, quindi sulla sanità mentale della produzione non ci spero tanto. Piuttosto preferisco vadano per il riavvio dell'universo, come fa sempre Moffat per tirarsi fuori da situazioni troppo incasinate, e anche se i Daleks si ricordano di nuovo di lui, pace.

Epico davvero! E il Doctor che ci ride su come un bambino mi è piaciuto tantissimo! *__________*

(Oswin Oswald è il nome più favoloso di qualsiasi companion ever, e non si discute :D )
Edited Date: 2012-09-02 06:33 pm (UTC)

Date: 2012-09-02 08:34 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] nausicaa83.livejournal.com
Mi hanno appena fatto notare su Tumblr che la nuova companion potrebbe essere una gemella, lontana cugina, bisnonna di Oswin. Non ci avevo proprio pensato, ma è un trope stra-abusato, quindi potrebbe ben essere. Tante teorie per nulla. ^^

Date: 2012-09-02 08:55 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] harriet-yuuko.livejournal.com
Io avevo pensato a una cosa tipo Gwen di Torchwood e la sua antenata in DW 1X03. Però apprezzerei di più una cosa totalmente diversa da "è una sua parente.".

Date: 2012-09-02 08:58 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] nausicaa83.livejournal.com
Concordo, andava bene nell'800, ma ora che sappiamo come funziona la genetica direi che è un trope un pò troppo inverosimile anche per uno show di fantascienza. A questo punto se no mi devono dire che Amy è una discendente della sacerdotessa di Fires of Pompei.

Date: 2012-09-03 08:34 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] cultnirvana.livejournal.com
Just watched it, and then ran to read what you had written. Well, after I checked the net after running around going, "But I thought she was the new companion. Isn't she?!?!" I LOVE Oswin! I was worried about a soap actress being the companion, but I love the thought of a companion who is highly intelligent and from what we would call the future. And the name?! I love it too! And I'm always iffy on Dalek episodes as they are used so often but, Yeap, this was nice, original and the proper scary Daleks from my childhood :)

Date: 2012-09-03 08:41 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] nausicaa83.livejournal.com
Oswin Oswald is the best name EVER. And I loved that in the end she was so smart, even smarter than the Doctor. Non to mention she called herself "the girl who can" which is a wonderful change of pace after all these years of Amy and lately River being the girls who waited. I was so not expecting that.

And the Daleks were amazing, properly scary, even if I wasn't expecting them to go the Cybermen way. Didn't think a Dalek would ever want to make another Dalek out of a human, since they have such a high opinion of their race. It wasn't really believable. Then they went for the ballerina scene, and that was so heartbreaking I completely accepted that storyline. Although I would have preferred it if the Doctor hadn't just wiped them out a minute later, he keeps committing genocide and it's really creepy. In this case, it was more of a "putting them out of their misery", I know, but it still hurts that he hasn't changed a bit. ;_;

May 2017

S M T W T F S
 12 345 6
7 8910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 28th, 2025 06:33 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios